Emerging Leaders & Leadership Coaching: Making the Most of High-Potential Employees

Avoid high-potential employee turnover with leadership development coaching.

Lately, there’s much talk about high-potential employees—employees who are highly intelligent and ambitious with good leadership qualities. The question around the water cooler is, “How do we treat our high-potential employees to ensure we get the most out of them?”

But when you look at the statistics on the retention of high-potential employees, perhaps the question should be even more rudimentary—something along the lines of, “How do we hold on to our high-potential employees?”

I recently came across an article in HR Magazine by Robert J. Grossman titled “The Care and Feeding of High-Potential Employees.” Grossman points out research done by the Corporate Leadership Council of the Corporate Executive Board that showed of 800 surveyed high-potential employees, 25% said they planned to change jobs within the next year. Among those searching for greener pastures, 64% felt their current employment was not contributing to their development.

Even more alarming is the fact that employers who did manage to hold on to high-performance employees said 40% of internal job moves made by top talent ended in failure.

Many of the organizations I work with have put plenty of time and effort into developing high-potential programs, but are frustrated by the difficulty they have had motivating and retaining those who, by all accounts, should be top performers. Grossman cites research that shows a divide between what employees think motivates high-po employees and what actually motivates them.

The strategies I found most relevant include:

• Give managers assessment tools they need and will use for selection. One reason why high-potential programs fail is that the selection process isn’t working. When managers don’t know how to identify high potentials, or when they don’t have a consistent criteria or method for identifying them, poor candidates sneak through. Executive coaching can help you find or develop the assessment tools you need,  can ensure that tools are applied consistently, and can aid you in reading assessments so that the right high-potential candidates are identified.

• Tap effective mentors. According to a study done by American Society for Training & Development, managerial productivity increased by 88% when mentoring was involved, versus only a 24% increase with training alone. But just as important as developing a mentoring program is finding the right mentors. Too often, organizations put time and money into mentoring, but they don’t spend nearly enough energy ensuring that those tapped to be mentors are cut out for the job, or that relationships make sense. Executive coaching can help you identify leaders who are suited to step into the mentoring role, and can come up with a plan that ensures relationships aren’t hit-or-miss.

• Align individual and company needs during the consultative process. Instead of dictating, make sure high potentials have a say in their development. I recently had a high-potential client who was offered a high-profile leadership role, with a significant increase in salary, benefits, and perks. However, the client was told that as part of the deal, he had to move across the country. The client, who had a son in his second year of high school and aging parents, chose to opt out and found a similar leadership role with a competitor. The organization lost an excellent employee, not to mention the time and money they spent training him. Instead of saying “If you do this then we’ll do that,” take the time to ensure that offers align with the employee’s needs. Leadership coaching can help you open up the dialogue to ensure that the interests and needs of both sides are balanced.

High potentials can be a huge asset to your organization, when approached correctly. When not approached correctly, they can be a huge source of frustration. To find out how leadership development coaching can help you identify high-potential employees and ensure that both company and individual needs are aligned, contact TurnKey Coaching Solutions at 281-469-4244.

Duplicate your star performers with TurnKey’s emerging leader programs, available throughout the whole country: Philadelphia, Houston (Tx), Dallas (Tx), Seattle(), Tampa (Fl), Los Angeles (Ca), Chicago (Il). See the full list of cities covered by our coaching programs for next generation leaders.

FAQ

What’s the point of leadership coaching for high-potential employees?
Leadership coaching helps you keep your best people and get real performance from them.
It’s not a feel-good perk. It’s a strategic move that shows high potentials their growth matters and ties their future to yours.

Why do high-potential programs fail?
They fail when selection and support are sloppy.
If leaders can’t clearly identify high potentials or don’t know how to use assessment tools well, the whole effort stalls and credibility disappears.

How does mentoring fit into coaching?
Mentoring works best when coaching sets it up right.
The right mentors, paired intentionally and supported properly, drive stronger productivity and development than training alone.

Should development be “one-size-fits-all”?
Absolutely not.
High potentials disengage fast when development feels generic, and coaching personalizes growth so it actually sticks.

How do you make offers that high potentials actually say “yes” to?
You align the opportunity with the person’s real life.
When leaders understand timing, location, and personal priorities, offers stop falling apart at the finish line.

What’s the risk of skipping leadership development?
You lose people you can’t afford to lose.
High potentials leave when they don’t see a future, and the cost shows up in turnover, disruption, and stalled momentum.

How do I start leveraging coaching for my high-potential employees?
Start by getting clear on your goals and gaps.
Then bring in leadership coaching to design assessments, mentoring, and growth plans that fit your organization. Connect with TurnKey Coaching Solutions here.

Can coaching really help with retention and engagement?
Yes, when it creates clarity and direction.
People stay when they see how their growth connects to the company’s future and their own.

Where are TurnKey’s emerging leader and high-potential programs offered?
They’re delivered nationwide and tailored to your people and market.
The focus stays on relevance, not geography.

What’s the first move after reading this FAQ?
Have a real conversation about your high-potential talent.
If you want support building leaders instead of losing them, reach out here: https://turnkeycoachingsolutions.com/contact-2/